The Editor-Writer Relationship: How to Gracefully Accept Feedback

The relationship between an editor and a writer is a cornerstone of creating polished, compelling stories. It’s a collaboration built on trust, respect, and the shared goal of producing the best possible work. However, receiving feedback, especially on something as personal as your writing, can sometimes feel like navigating a minefield.

Here's how to approach this relationship and feedback process with an open mind and a productive attitude.

1. Remember the Shared Goal

Both you and your editor want the same thing: for your story to shine. Understanding that feedback is aimed at improving your work, not tearing it down, helps frame critiques in a positive light.

💡 Mindset Shift: See your editor as a partner in success rather than a critic.

2. Don’t Take It Personally

Your story is close to your heart, but feedback is about the writing, not you as a person. Keeping this separation clear allows you to focus on the suggestions without feeling defensive.

💡 Tip: Take a deep breath before reading feedback. Give yourself time to process it objectively.

3. Be Open to Change

Writing is rewriting, and even the most celebrated authors undergo edits. While some feedback may challenge your vision, consider how it could strengthen your work.

💡 Practical Approach: Start by experimenting with suggested changes in one scene. Sometimes seeing the improvement can help you embrace broader edits.

4. Ask Questions

If something isn’t clear, ask! Editors appreciate writers who engage with the feedback process. It shows you’re invested in improving your work and value their insights.

💡 Example Questions:

• “Can you clarify why this scene feels off to you?”

• “What do you think would make this character more engaging?”

5. Pick Your Battles

While you should consider all feedback, it’s okay to stand your ground on things central to your vision. A good editor respects your creative choices when they’re intentional and well-reasoned.

💡 Strategy: Distinguish between preferences and principles. Be flexible with the former and firm with the latter.

6. Trust the Process

The editorial process can feel daunting, but trust in your editor’s expertise and your ability to adapt. Each revision is a step closer to a stronger story.

💡 Encouragement: “Your first draft is just you telling yourself the story.” Revisions are where the magic happens.

7. Show Gratitude

Editors work hard to help your story reach its potential. Acknowledging their efforts fosters a positive working relationship and sets the stage for future collaborations.

💡 Small Gesture: A simple “thank you” email after receiving edits goes a long way.

8. Reflect and Apply

After implementing feedback, reflect on how it improved your story. This reflection builds your skills as a writer, making you more confident and less intimidated by feedback in the future.

💡 Pro Tip: Keep a notebook or file of lessons learned from edits for future reference.

In Summary

The editor-writer relationship thrives on communication, trust, and a willingness to grow. By approaching feedback with an open mind and a positive attitude, you’ll not only strengthen your story but also develop as a writer. Remember: every edit is a stepping stone toward mastery.

Take a deep breath, dive into the feedback, and watch your story transform!